- What are fundamental rights?
- Constitutional basis and the Objectives Resolution
- Rights relating to persons and body
- Rights relating to freedom
- Rights relating to religion
- Rights relating to property
- Rights relating to equality
- Right to education
- Rights relating to non-discrimination
- Rights relating to language
- Can fundamental rights be suspended?
- Past exam questions and answers
1. What are fundamental rights?
Fundamental rights are those rights that are guaranteed by the constitution itself rather than by ordinary law. This distinction matters a great deal in practice. An ordinary legal right can be taken away or changed by parliament through simple legislation. A fundamental right cannot. It is placed beyond the reach of the legislature, the executive, and any other organ of the state.
In Pakistan, Articles 8 to 28 of the 1973 Constitution set out the full list of fundamental rights. Article 8 establishes the foundational rule: any law that contradicts these rights is void from the moment it is made.
2. Constitutional basis and the Objectives Resolution
The Objectives Resolution, passed in 1949, forms the philosophical foundation of Pakistan’s constitution. It was made a substantive part of the 1973 Constitution and is often called the Magna Carta of the Pakistani constitutional order. It sets out the broad principles within which all fundamental rights must be understood and interpreted.
Article 8 gives fundamental rights their legal force. It states that no law, custom, or usage that conflicts with these rights will be enforced. The only exceptions are narrow and specifically listed in the constitution itself, such as laws relating to the armed forces and certain laws listed in the First Schedule.
3. Rights relating to persons and body
Security of person — Article 9
No person can be deprived of life or liberty except in accordance with law. This is the most basic protection a constitution can offer. It means the state cannot arrest, detain, or harm a person without lawful authority. The rule of law begins here.
Safeguards against arrest and detention — Article 10
When a person is arrested, the police must tell them the grounds of their arrest. The arrested person has the right to consult a lawyer and to be represented by one. Most importantly, every arrested person must be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours. These protections exist to prevent arbitrary detention and to ensure that no one simply disappears into custody without legal process.
Right to a fair trial — Article 10A
This right was added through the 18th Constitutional Amendment and is one of the most significant additions to the fundamental rights chapter. Every person is entitled to a fair trial and due process in the determination of their civil rights or in any criminal charge against them. Courts cannot be bypassed, and decisions affecting a person’s legal rights must follow proper judicial procedure.
Prohibition of slavery and forced labour — Article 11
Slavery is abolished in Pakistan and is completely forbidden. All forms of forced labour and human trafficking are prohibited. The constitution also specifically protects children: no child under the age of 14 can be employed in a factory, mine, or any other hazardous occupation.
Protection against retrospective punishment — Article 12
A person cannot be punished for something that was not a crime at the time they did it. Nor can they be given a harsher punishment than what was prescribed by law at the time of the offence. This principle, known in legal Latin as nullum crimen sine lege, is a cornerstone of any fair criminal justice system.
Protection against double punishment and self-incrimination — Article 13
No person can be tried or punished for the same offence more than once. This is the protection against double jeopardy. The article also protects against self-incrimination: no one can be forced to give evidence against themselves. Both protections reflect the fundamental principle that the state bears the burden of proving guilt.
Inviolability of dignity of man — Article 14
Human dignity cannot be violated. This is stated plainly in the constitution and is not subject to any law. The privacy of the home is also protected, though subject to lawful authority. Torture for the purpose of extracting evidence is expressly and absolutely prohibited.
4. Rights relating to freedom
Freedom of movement — Article 15
Every citizen has the right to move freely throughout Pakistan, to reside anywhere, and to settle in any part of the country. This freedom cannot be taken away without lawful justification.
Freedom of assembly — Article 16
Citizens have the right to gather peacefully and without arms. Public gatherings for lawful purposes are protected. Reasonable restrictions can be placed in the interest of public order, but the state cannot simply ban peaceful assembly.
Freedom of association — Article 17
Every citizen can form or join associations and unions. Citizens who are not in government service can also form or join political parties. Restrictions are only permissible when they are reasonable and relate to the sovereignty of Pakistan, public order, or morality.
Freedom of trade, business and profession — Article 18
Every citizen has the right to choose any lawful profession, occupation, or business. The state cannot prevent someone from earning a living in a lawful way without proper legal basis.
Freedom of speech and expression — Article 19
Citizens enjoy freedom of speech, expression, and press. This freedom is subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of the glory of Islam, the integrity and security of Pakistan, public order, decency, and the prevention of contempt of court. The key word is “reasonable” — restrictions must be proportionate and justified.
Right to information — Article 19A
This was another important addition through the 18th Amendment. Every citizen has the right to access information in all matters of public importance. This right promotes transparency and accountability in government. It is subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by law.
5. Rights relating to religion
Freedom to profess religion — Article 20
Every citizen has the right to freely profess, practise, and propagate their religion. This right is subject to law, public order, and morality, but it means the state cannot force anyone to change or hide their faith.
Safeguard against religious taxes — Article 21
No person can be forced to pay a special tax for the support or propagation of any religion other than their own. This protects citizens from being made to financially support religious practices they do not follow.
Religious educational institutions — Article 22
Every religious community has the right to establish its own educational institutions and to teach its children its own religion. No student at a public institution can be required to receive religious instruction or attend religious worship of a faith other than their own.
6. Rights relating to property
Freedom to acquire property — Article 23
Every citizen can acquire, hold, and dispose of property anywhere in Pakistan. This right is subject to the constitution and the law, but it means the state cannot arbitrarily prevent citizens from owning property.
Protection of property rights — Article 24
No person can be deprived of their property without lawful authority. If the state acquires property for a public purpose, it must do so through proper legal process and must pay fair compensation. Arbitrary seizure of property is unconstitutional.
7. Rights relating to equality
Equality of citizens — Article 25
All citizens are equal before the law and are entitled to equal protection of the law. There is to be no discrimination on the basis of sex. At the same time, the constitution allows the state to make special provisions for the protection of women and children, recognising that genuine equality sometimes requires treating different groups differently.
8. Right to education — Article 25A
This is one of the three rights added by the 18th Constitutional Amendment and one of the most practically significant. The state is required to provide free and compulsory education to all children between the ages of five and sixteen. This is not a policy aspiration but a constitutional obligation.
9. Rights relating to non-discrimination
Right of access to public places — Article 26
Every citizen has the right to access public places. No one can be denied entry to shops, hotels, restaurants, or entertainment venues on the basis of race, religion, caste, sex, or place of birth. Places of worship are excluded from this definition and are not considered public places for this purpose.
Non-discrimination in public service — Article 27
No qualified citizen can be discriminated against in appointment to any government service on the basis of race, religion, caste, sex, residence, or place of birth. Merit must be the basis of public appointments.
10. Rights relating to language — Article 28
While Urdu is the national language of Pakistan under Article 251, the constitution also protects linguistic minorities. Any group of citizens with a distinct language, script, or culture has the right to preserve and promote it, and to establish institutions for that purpose. Cultural diversity is thus given constitutional protection.
11. Can fundamental rights be suspended?
Fundamental rights are not absolute in the sense that they can never under any circumstances be limited. During a constitutionally proclaimed state of emergency under Articles 232 and 233, certain fundamental rights may be suspended. Article 8(5) also makes clear that rights cannot be suspended except as the constitution itself expressly provides.
The logic behind this is straightforward. If the state itself is under existential threat, the framework that protects individual rights becomes meaningless. But this power to suspend rights is narrow, temporary, and subject to strict constitutional conditions. It is not a blank cheque for the government.
12. Past exam questions and answers
Discuss the significance of fundamental rights in a democratic state with reference to retrospective punishment, double punishment, and dignity of man. (2019-S)
Fundamental rights limit state power and protect individual liberty. Articles 12, 13, and 14 specifically prohibit ex post facto laws, double jeopardy, self-incrimination, and torture. These protections are not optional courtesies; they are constitutional obligations that the courts must enforce.
Explain the scope of fundamental rights in Pakistan with reference to fair trial, freedom of association, and equality of citizens. (2019-A)
Articles 10A, 17, and 25 respectively guarantee these rights. Their scope covers all citizens without exception. Restrictions are permissible only when they are reasonable and in the genuine public interest, not merely convenient for the government.
Which fundamental rights were newly inserted through the 18th Constitutional Amendment? (2018-A)
The three newly inserted rights are the right to a fair trial under Article 10A, the right to information under Article 19A, and the right to free and compulsory education under Article 25A. These additions significantly strengthened the fundamental rights chapter.
What safeguards has the 1973 constitution provided against arrest and detention? (2017-S)
Article 10 requires that an arrested person be informed of the grounds of arrest, be allowed to consult and be represented by a lawyer, and be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours. These protections apply to every person arrested in Pakistan regardless of the nature of the alleged offence.
How are fundamental rights different from the principles of policy? (2017-A)
Fundamental rights under Articles 8 to 28 are justiciable, meaning courts can directly enforce them. The principles of policy under Articles 29 to 40 are non-justiciable guidelines for the state. They represent goals to work towards, not enforceable legal obligations.
Discuss the newly inserted rights of education, fair trial, and freedom of information. (2014-A)
Articles 25A, 10A, and 19A were added by the 18th Amendment. Article 25A makes free education for children aged 5 to 16 a state obligation. Article 10A guarantees fair trial and due process. Article 19A gives citizens the right to access information on matters of public importance.